Let football be goofy

On a recent episode of Blue 58, a listener asked whether there’s a football equivalent of “freestyle” soccer. That is, do football players ever do anything that lets them show off their skills in a more unstructured — dare I say, “fun” — environment?

And truthfully, I can’t think of anything. The closest I got when answering their question was bringing up the Pro Bowl Skills Challenge. But that’s just a glorified obstacle course, and unlike the freestyle soccer stuff, it’s application to “real” football is limited. It would have looked fantastic on late-90s Nickelodeon, but it’s not football, nor is it really all that close to football.

Going back a bit further, you can get a little closer to freestyle football with the Quarterback Challenge, but that, too, is just a demonstration of skills. There’s no art to it. There’s no soul. It’s pure competition: who can throw the farthest, who can throw the most accurately, who can do the quarterback things the best.

The unfortunate fact is that football is just not very given to art. I find beauty in the game, but there’s very little inherent beauty to it. It’s like brutalist architecture: if there’s beauty there, it’s in the conscious absence of it. Football is a game designed to be limited to its most efficient essence. You have to find the beauty in the relentless, precise churning of the machine.

I wish it wasn’t that way. I wish we could find ways to let football be silly and goofy. I wish we could have things like the NFL’s Fastest Man competition again without unending concerns about offseason injuries or who’s going to get made fun of on the internet for running slightly slowly. I wish that people could play football with a smile on their face. It’s impossible to imagine the joy pouring off someone performing soccer tricks ever being present in the context of American football. How could it be? You’ve got to keep your head on a swivel or someone will remove it from your body.

But maybe the people can save us. If we get over the idea that everyone who approaches a microphone on behalf of a football team has to be an ultra-polished quote parrot, maybe we can get some more personalities that are in this game for fun. If the game itself can’t be a beacon of joy, maybe we can let the people shine some more.

It’s worth hoping for. If football is only ever going to be an increasingly efficient exercise of brutal precision, maybe the people can bring the silliness to humanize our Sunday afternoons. 

EditorialJon Meerdink